My daughter was killed by two kids. A kid who can't even speak, Ray Harris, and his stupid little friend, Johnny O'Shea, chased Katie, beat her with a hockey stick, and shot her through the head. God knows why they did it. Maybe Silent Ray wanted to keep Brendan from moving to Vegas. Maybe Brendan was the only person he cared about. Or maybe they were just two kids being idiots and my poor daughter was just in the wrong place at the wrong time. Aside from all of this confusion and raw anger flowing through my head, I always found my way back to one fact. A single, undeniable fact that I would have to face at some point.
I killed the wrong man.
Dave knelt before me and begged me to believe that he killed a child molester, not my daughter. But I allowed my hand to slice the knife through his stomach anyways.
After the fact, as I was walking on Gannon Street, I pondered the level of my guilt. So I killed the wrong guy. But just because he didn't kill Katie doesn't mean he was an innocent man. He still killed that child molester. So, in a twisted sense, Dave still deserved to die. And that idea helped me to ease some of my culpability.
Later, Sean walked up and told me that they'd found the culprits, a couple of kids, and that Dave Boyle was missing. Then, after just a glance, he knew. He saw right through me like a freaking window. I repressed my panic with the knowledge that there was never going to be anything to link me to that murder, just like there was nothing to link me to the murder of Just Ray Harris. So, at that point, I still had the freedom to make a choice. My Katie is gone. Rather than living with the weighty regret of a premature murder, I am going to live every moment in loving memory of her. I will enjoy the time I have with Annabeth, Nadine, and Sarah, creating new memories, while remembering every precious moment I had with Katie.
Jimmy Marcus